Mployer Advisor

Find Top Insurance Brokers In Columbus, Indiana

Showing 12 of 85 results

Sort by:

Search by

Mployer Advisor independently rates each insurance advisor using a proprietary score called an “M Score”.
An advisor cannot pay to influence their score.

Hylant Group - Bloomington, IN

Hylant Group - Bloomington, IN

Bloomington, Indiana

Named 13 consecutive years to the “Best Places to Work in Insurance” list, Hylant was founded in 1935. We’re among the largest privately-held insurance brokerages in the U.S., with offices in Ohio, Mi...

mScore

Score

5/5

Proprietary rating

Service focus:

Employer size expertise:


Health, Dental, Vision, Life, Disability, Workers Compensation, Voluntary Insurance, Liability, Retirement

51-100, 101-250, 251-1,000, 1,001-2,500, 2,501+

Hylant Group - Bloomington, IN

Hylant Group - Bloomington, IN

Bloomington, Indiana

mScore

Score

Proprietary rating

5/5

Named 13 consecutive years to the “Best Places to Work in Insurance” list, Hylant was founded in 1935. We’re among the l...

Walkerhughes Insurance - Greenwood, IN

Walkerhughes Insurance - Greenwood, IN

Greenwood, Indiana

Walkerhughes Greenwood is a regional insurance brokerage firm serving several areas with a local office in Greenwood, IN. WalkerHughes makes sure their customers have an insurance person, not just a p...

mScore

Score

4/5

Proprietary rating

Service focus:

Employer size expertise:


Health, Dental, Vision, Life, Disability, Voluntary Insurance, Liability, Retirement

51-100, 101-250, 251-1,000, 1,001-2,500, 2,501+

Walkerhughes Insurance - Greenwood, IN

Walkerhughes Insurance - Greenwood, IN

Greenwood, Indiana

mScore

Score

Proprietary rating

4/5

Walkerhughes Greenwood is a regional insurance brokerage firm serving several areas with a local office in Greenwood, IN...

Huntington Insurance - Greenwood, IN

Huntington Insurance - Greenwood, IN

Greenwood, Indiana

Huntington provides employee benefits and group health insurance to employers in the Indianapolis-Carmel-Anderson, IN Metro Area. Providing comprehensive medical benefits to employees and voluntary be...

mScore

Score

5/5

Proprietary rating

Service focus:

Employer size expertise:


Health, Dental, Vision, Life, Disability, Property Casualty, Voluntary Insurance, Liability, Retirement

51-100, 101-250, 251-1,000, 1,001-2,500, 2,501+

Huntington Insurance - Greenwood, IN

Huntington Insurance - Greenwood, IN

Greenwood, Indiana

mScore

Score

Proprietary rating

5/5

Huntington provides employee benefits and group health insurance to employers in the Indianapolis-Carmel-Anderson, IN Me...

EPIC Insurance Brokers and Consultants - Plainfield, IN

EPIC Insurance Brokers and Consultants - Plainfield, IN

Plainfield, Indiana

EPIC Insurance Brokers & Consultants has a depth of industry expertise across key lines of insurance, including risk management, property and casualty, employee benefits, unique specialty program insu...

mScore

Score

5/5

Proprietary rating

Service focus:

Employer size expertise:


Health, Dental, Vision, Life, Disability

51-100, 101-250, 251-1,000, 1,001-2,500, 2,501+

EPIC Insurance Brokers and Consultants - Plainfield, IN

EPIC Insurance Brokers and Consultants - Plainfield, IN

Plainfield, Indiana

mScore

Score

Proprietary rating

5/5

EPIC Insurance Brokers & Consultants has a depth of industry expertise across key lines of insurance, including risk man...

Need Help Selecting an Insurance Broker?
Let our team create a custom shortlist for you
Nefouse & Associates

Nefouse & Associates

Indianapolis, Indiana

Nefouse & Associates, LLC are a local insurance broker serving the Indianapolis region and specialize in helping individuals, small businesses, and large employers find affordable health care coverage...

mScore

Score

5/5

Proprietary rating

Service focus:

Employer size expertise:


Health, Dental, Vision, Life, Disability

101-250, 251-1,000, 1,001-2,500, 2,501+

Nefouse & Associates

Nefouse & Associates

Indianapolis, Indiana

mScore

Score

Proprietary rating

5/5

Nefouse & Associates, LLC are a local insurance broker serving the Indianapolis region and specialize in helping individ...

EPIC Insurance Brokers and Consultants - Franklin, IN

EPIC Insurance Brokers and Consultants - Franklin, IN

Franklin, Indiana

EPIC Insurance Brokers & Consultants has a depth of industry expertise across key lines of insurance, including risk management, property and casualty, employee benefits, unique specialty program insu...

mScore

Score

5/5

Proprietary rating

Service focus:

Employer size expertise:


Health, Dental, Vision, Life, Disability

51-100, 101-250, 251-1,000, 1,001-2,500, 2,501+

EPIC Insurance Brokers and Consultants - Franklin, IN

EPIC Insurance Brokers and Consultants - Franklin, IN

Franklin, Indiana

mScore

Score

Proprietary rating

5/5

EPIC Insurance Brokers & Consultants has a depth of industry expertise across key lines of insurance, including risk man...

JA Benefits

JA Benefits

Bedford, Indiana

JA Benefits Bedford, an insurance advisor committed to helping employees in Bedford with clients across the area, has been delivering difference to the field of employee benefits since 1988. The compa...

mScore

Score

5/5

Proprietary rating

Service focus:

Employer size expertise:


Health, Dental, Vision, Life, Disability, Property Casualty, Workers Compensation, Voluntary Insurance, Liability, Retirement

2,501+

JA Benefits

JA Benefits

Bedford, Indiana

mScore

Score

Proprietary rating

5/5

JA Benefits Bedford, an insurance advisor committed to helping employees in Bedford with clients across the area, has be...

Walkerhughes Insurance - Indianapolis, IN

Walkerhughes Insurance - Indianapolis, IN

Indianapolis, Indiana

Walkerhughes provides employee benefits and group health insurance to all sizes of employers in the Indianapolis-Carmel-Anderson, IN, Metro Area. With total employment in the Indianapolis-Carmel-Ander...

mScore

Score

4/5

Proprietary rating

Service focus:

Employer size expertise:


Health, Dental, Vision, Life, Disability, Voluntary Insurance, Liability, Retirement

51-100, 101-250, 251-1,000, 1,001-2,500, 2,501+

Walkerhughes Insurance - Indianapolis, IN

Walkerhughes Insurance - Indianapolis, IN

Indianapolis, Indiana

mScore

Score

Proprietary rating

4/5

Walkerhughes provides employee benefits and group health insurance to all sizes of employers in the Indianapolis-Carmel-...

Gregory & Appel Insurance

Gregory & Appel Insurance

Indianapolis, Indiana

Gregory & Appel is a fiercely independent risk management advisor, proactively guiding people and businesses through the complexities of insurance and employee benefits with smart, future-focused solu...

mScore

Score

5/5

Proprietary rating

Service focus:

Employer size expertise:


Health, Dental, Vision, Life, Disability

51-100, 101-250, 251-1,000, 1,001-2,500, 2,501+

Gregory & Appel Insurance

Gregory & Appel Insurance

Indianapolis, Indiana

mScore

Score

Proprietary rating

5/5

Gregory & Appel is a fiercely independent risk management advisor, proactively guiding people and businesses through the...

Key Benefit Administrators - Indianapolis, IN

Key Benefit Administrators - Indianapolis, IN

Indianapolis, Indiana

Key Benefit Administrators, LLC is a leading financial insurance firm providing employee benefits and group health insurance to all sizes of employers in the Indianapolis-Carmel-Anderson, IN Metro Are...

mScore

Score

5/5

Proprietary rating

Service focus:

Employer size expertise:


Health, Dental, Vision, Life, Disability, Voluntary Insurance, Liability, Retirement

1-10, 11-50, 51-100, 101-250, 251-1,000

Key Benefit Administrators - Indianapolis, IN

Key Benefit Administrators - Indianapolis, IN

Indianapolis, Indiana

mScore

Score

Proprietary rating

5/5

Key Benefit Administrators, LLC is a leading financial insurance firm providing employee benefits and group health insur...

Shepherd Insurance - Vernon, IN

Shepherd Insurance - Vernon, IN

Vernon, Indiana

Shepherd Insurance is a regional insurance brokerage firm dedicated to mitigating life's uncertainties. They offer security and peace of mind to individuals, families, and businesses across the countr...

mScore

Score

5/5

Proprietary rating

Service focus:

Employer size expertise:


Health, Dental, Vision, Life, Disability, Voluntary Insurance, Liability, Retirement

51-100, 101-250, 251-1,000, 1,001-2,500, 2,501+

Shepherd Insurance - Vernon, IN

Shepherd Insurance - Vernon, IN

Vernon, Indiana

mScore

Score

Proprietary rating

5/5

Shepherd Insurance is a regional insurance brokerage firm dedicated to mitigating life's uncertainties. They offer secur...

Robertson Ryan and Associates - Avon, IN

Robertson Ryan and Associates - Avon, IN

Avon, Indiana

Robertson Ryan provides employee benefits and group health insurance to all sizes of employers in the Indianapolis-Carmel-Anderson, IN, Metro Area. Providing comprehensive medical benefits to employee...

mScore

Score

5/5

Proprietary rating

Service focus:

Employer size expertise:


Health, Dental, Vision, Life, Disability, Voluntary Insurance, Liability, Retirement

1-10, 11-50, 51-100, 101-250, 251-1,000

Robertson Ryan and Associates - Avon, IN

Robertson Ryan and Associates - Avon, IN

Avon, Indiana

mScore

Score

Proprietary rating

5/5

Robertson Ryan provides employee benefits and group health insurance to all sizes of employers in the Indianapolis-Carme...

  • <
  • 1
  • 2
  • 3
  • 4
  • 5
  • ...
  • >

Frequently asked questions

How can I find an insurance broker near Columbus, Indiana?

Mployer Advisor lets you search for Columbus, Indiana-area insurance brokers, advisors, or consultants in one place. Narrow your results at the top of this page by M Score rating, company size, the type of insurance you're looking for, or even your industry.

How are insurance brokers in Columbus, Indiana paid?

Most often business insurance brokers are paid through commissions and fees. Small and mid-size companies' insurance brokers are typically paid through commissions. These are paid to the broker by the insurance company you select. Larger companies often set up a fee-based arrangement instead of a commission-based arrangement with their broker or consultant partner.

Can I compare insurance brokers in the Columbus, Indiana area?

It can feel overwhelming to sift through the many brokers in the Columbus, Indiana area. It's why Mployer Advisor provides a free comprehensive list of all Columbus, Indiana insurance brokers. We include overviews, customer reviews, and our independent rating called an M Score. The higher the M Score, the broader the broker's experience. With an M Score, you are empowered to choose the best broker for your company.

What is the difference between an insurance broker, agent, and a consultant in Columbus, Indiana?

Insurance brokers, agents, and consultants in Columbus, Indiana all have a similar role as they help a business or individual select an insurance company and plan.

  • Agents represent one specific insurance company only for the most part, they sell that insurance company's products.
  • Brokers are often independent and are able to quote multiple insurance company's prices. They are usually paid through a commission from the insurance company selected.
  • Consultants are usually brokers as well, but they work with larger companies and are paid on a fee based arrangement, similar to general management consultants. That is why they are often called consultants.
You can use Mployer Advisor to find Columbus, Indiana based insurance brokers and consultants.

Should I hire an independent Columbus, Indiana insurance broker?

Finding the best insurance for your business can feel intimidating, as there are a lot of options in Columbus, Indiana. For most organizations, it's beneficial to hire an independent broker.

An insurance broker local to the Columbus, Indiana area will have familiarity to the Columbus, Indiana healthcare systems and insurance plans. This gives Columbus, Indiana insurance brokers unique insight that others from out of the area may not have. Also, independent insurance brokers are able to quote you prices for your employees from a wider range of insurance carriers and therefore can often find prices and plans that better fit unique needs.

How do I choose a benefits broker in Columbus, Indiana?

It can feel overwhelming to sift through the many brokers in the Columbus, Indiana area. That is why Mployer Advisor provides a free comprehensive list of all Columbus, Indiana insurance brokers. We include overviews, customer reviews, and our independent rating called an M Score.

Can I change my insurance broker?

If you are currently working with a broker, it's important to know that you can always change your insurance broker. Even if you're happy with your broker, it's a good idea to evaluate Columbus, Indiana-based insurance brokers often.

If you do not feel like you as a business are not receiving the right price or level of service you deserve, you should evaluate a new insurance broker. Mployer Advisor provides a free list of Columbus, Indiana based insurance brokers and consultants for you to review including customer ratings and independent scores.

Will my insurance broker handle my insurance claims?

Insurance brokers in Columbus, Indiana do not specifically handle claims, that is the role of your insurance carrier. Your insurance broker can help you navigate the claims process if needed, especially for large and or questionable claims.

Do all Columbus, Indiana brokers have an M Score?

We work hard to ensure every M Score is accurate, helpful, and pushes the insurance brokerage industry to be open and transparent. It's calculated using a brokerage's breadth and depth of experience across industries, employer sizes, and offerings. An industry-first, the M Score is available for most Columbus, Indiana-based brokers and more are being added every day.

When is the best time to shop for a new insurance broker?

Making the right insurance choice saves money, helps retain the best employees, and can prevent unforeseen costs. An insurance broker is an invaluable asset so the best time to shop for a new Columbus, Indiana-area insurance broker is earlier than you think. Extra time helps identify the skills and capabilities expected of your ideal broker, lets you understand how different brokers deliver different results, and gives you the ability to use neutral third-party tools like Mployer Advisor to evaluate broker options.

Insider Information For Employers

Podcast: Why More Companies Are Banking on Unconventional Employee Benefits

In Employee Benefits

Read more

For Employers

1

Podcast: Why More Companies Are Banking on Unconventional Employee Benefits

In Employee Benefits