Henderson Brothers is a leading independent insurance, employee benefits, retirement plan consulting and personal money management firm headquartered in Pittsburgh, Pennsylvania. Serving individuals, families, and organizations across a wide range of industries, we’re more than a team of experts, we are people who care. We’re proactive by nature and personal by choice, combining insight with presence to build relationships that last and results that matter. Whether supporting your growth, protecting your people, or helping strengthen your community, we’re in it with you.

View Profile

READY-2-INSURE - WESTERVILLE, OH

Westerville, Ohio

At Ready-2-Insure, we specialize in supporting Ohio-based employers who are moving past the early growth phase and need a partner equipped for a more complex, hands-on benefits strategy. Unlike online marketplaces that shine at fitting tiny teams with quick, basic plans, we thrive at delivering deeper, relationship-driven guidance for organizations ready for something beyond a one-size-fits-all model. We pair deep industry expertise and Ohio-grown insight with cutting-edge technology to tailor benefit packages that align with your unique workforce and long-term goals. Forget endless online comparisons—our advisors work alongside you to navigate options, ensure compliance, and secure meaningful coverage for businesses up to 500 employees. With Ready-2-Insure, you gain a seasoned ally who understands the local market, anticipates your evolving needs, and provides the kind of personal, strategic support that scales as you do.

View Profile

HYLANT GROUP - COLUMBUS, OH

Dublin, Ohio

Hylant's Columbus, Ohio office, based in Dublin and part of the Hylant firm, works with mid-sized employers across professional business services, religious and non-profit organizations, healthcare and social services, manufacturing, and retail services. Its placement work spans self-funded arrangements, medical coverage, PPO plans, prescription drug benefits, ancillary lines, and retirement plans. Employer clients including ICP, Inc. are well rated by their employees for benefits. Example carriers include UnitedHealthcare, Elevance and Reliance Standard Life.

View Profile

HUMMEL GROUP - BERLIN, OH

Berlin, Ohio

The Hummel Group office in Berlin, Ohio operates as part of Hummel Group. Its employer clients concentrate in manufacturing, financial activities, construction, data, media and telecom, and healthcare and social services, and the office works with small and mid-sized employers. The office places both self-funded and fully insured arrangements, with medical coverage including PPO plans and prescription drug benefits, along with ancillary lines, retirement plans and mega wrap arrangements. Clients including Hummel Group, Inc. and FoxHire, LLC are well rated by their employees for benefits. Example carriers include AultCare, Community Insurance and Medical Mutual.

View Profile

TABIT ARGANBRIGHT & HAZELBAKER - COLUMBUS, OH

Westerville, Ohio

Tabit Arganbright & Hazelbaker's Columbus, OH office operates from Westerville, Ohio as part of the Tabit Arganbright & Hazelbaker firm. Its work centers on mid-sized employers, placing both self-funded and fully insured arrangements with medical coverage and PPO plan designs, along with ancillary lines and retirement plans. Example carriers include Elevance, Community Insurance and UnitedHealthcare.

View Profile

ASSUREDPARTNERS - COLUMBUS, OH

Columbus, Ohio

AssuredPartners' Columbus, Ohio office operates as part of the AssuredPartners brokerage network, serving employer clients across manufacturing, healthcare and social services, professional business services, construction and retail services. The office works with small, mid-sized and large employers alike. Its placement work spans self-funded arrangements alongside fully insured medical structures including PPO and HMO plans, with prescription drug coverage, ancillary lines and retirement plans also part of the book. The office additionally handles mega wrap arrangements and collectively bargained plans. Employer clients including Steven Schaefer Associates, Inc. and Stevens Engineers & Constructors, Inc. are well rated by their employees for benefits. Example carriers include Elevance, UnitedHealthcare and Cigna.

View Profile

Need Help Selecting an Insurance Advisor?

Let our team create a custom shortlist for you.

SHAWAN-MARQUIS AGENCY, INC. - COLUMBUS, OH

Columbus, Ohio

The Columbus, Ohio office of Shawan-Marquis Agency, Inc. operates as part of the Shawan-Marquis Agency, Inc. organization, serving mid-sized employers across construction, manufacturing, professional business services, and healthcare and social services. Its work spans both self-funded and fully insured arrangements, with medical coverage placed through PPO and HMO structures alongside prescription drug benefits, ancillary lines, retirement plans, and mega wrap arrangements. Employer clients including Eagle Crusher Co. Inc and Forge Biologics, Inc. are well rated by their employees for benefits. Example carriers include Elevance, Community Insurance and Anthem BCBS.

View Profile

THE WORKSITE GROUP - COLUMBUS, OH

Columbus, Ohio

The Worksite Group's Columbus, Ohio office operates as part of The Worksite Group. Its employer clients span healthcare and social services, manufacturing, construction, wholesale trade and retail services, and the office works with mid-sized and large employers. Its programs center on self-funded arrangements and medical coverage, including PPO plans, along with ancillary lines, retirement plans and mega wrap structures. Clients including Virtus Corporation Inc. and Stealth Enterprises LLC are well rated by their employees for benefits. Example carriers include Elevance, UnitedHealthcare and Cigna.

View Profile

GALLAGHER - COLUMBUS, OH

Dublin, Ohio

Gallagher's Columbus, OH office, located in Dublin, Ohio, operates as part of the Gallagher brokerage. Its work centers on employers in healthcare and social services as well as financial activities, and it serves mid-sized and large employer clients. The office places medical coverage, including self-funded arrangements, along with ancillary lines and retirement plans. Employer clients including Stein Ancillary Services, LLC and Traylor Bros., Inc. are well rated by their employees for benefits. Example carriers include UnitedHealthcare, Aetna and Kaiser Permanente.

View Profile

BAC - COLUMBUS, OH

Reynoldsburg, Ohio

BAC - COLUMBUS, OH is an office of BAC located in Reynoldsburg, Ohio. Its work centers on manufacturing and professional business services employers, primarily small and mid-sized organizations. The office places both self-funded and fully insured arrangements, with medical and prescription drug coverage, ancillary lines, retirement plans and mega wrap programs. Employer clients including ONETA COMPANY and NUTIS PRESS, INC. are well rated by their employees for benefits. Example carriers include American National, Companion Life Insurance Company and Cigna.

View Profile

HUNTINGTON INSURANCE - COLUMBUS, OH

Columbus, Ohio

The Columbus, Ohio office of Huntington operates as part of the broader Huntington organization, serving employer clients across manufacturing, healthcare and social services, professional business services, wholesale trade, and administrative and support services. Its work spans small, mid-sized and large employers. The office places self-funded arrangements alongside medical coverage structured as PPO and HMO plans, prescription drug benefits, ancillary lines and retirement plans. Its experience also extends to mega wrap arrangements, collectively bargained plans and MEWA structures. Employer clients including D.W. Lift Sales, Inc. and Westminster Village Greenwood, Inc. are well rated by their employees for benefits. Example carriers include Elevance, AultCare and UnitedHealthcare.

View Profile

RANKIN INSURANCE SERVICES - ZANESVILLE, OH

Zanesville, Ohio

Rankin Insurance Services operates as a standalone office in Zanesville, Ohio, working with mid-sized employers. Its work spans both self-funded and fully insured arrangements, with medical coverage including PPO plans, along with ancillary lines and retirement plans. Example carriers include Medical Mutual, Tokio Marine HCC and Principal Financial.

View Profile

FAQs