Insurance Broker

Best Insurance Brokers in Tampa, Florida

UPDATED ON
September 28, 2022
Sarah Ann Johnson
Print Friendly and PDF

Are you looking for a new employee benefits broker but don’t know where to start or how to tell a good office from a bad one? Here at Mployer Advisor, we’ve done all the hard work for you.  Employee benefits plans are an integral part of an employee’s compensation package, but choosing the wrong broker could result in costly plans and frustrating communication gaps. Luckily, we have done extensive research to evaluate and score Tampa's employee benefits brokers to bring you a list featuring the city's best of the best.

How Are Brokers Scored?

We score brokers based on the following metrics: 

1. Breadth and depth of experience across:​

  • Employer industries​
  • Employer sizes ​
  • Insurance products
  • Digital presence

2. Historical data collected over three years.

3. Online reviews from employers on our site, the broker’s site, and on the broker’s Google Business Profile.  

4. Mployer Advisor's industry-first M Score rating. An “M Score” is a quantitative rating of each brokerage based on historical data used to gauge business experience, expertise, and customer satisfaction. Brokers can offer products ranging from individual to business and from medical to voluntary benefits. Our goal is to match employers with the best employee benefits brokers that can address each organization's unique needs, including comparing benefits plans by employee size, region, and industry. A solid knowledge base in those areas allows a broker to design customized plans and tailored consulting services. Mployer Advisor uses public and proprietary datasets to weigh experience and customer service to generate each brokerage's M score.

Why You Can Trust Mployer Advisor

Transparency is at the heart of our mission at Mployer Advisor. It is our passion and our purpose. We were founded with the intent of disrupting a marketplace that, historically, has resisted transparency and, in some cases, benefited from its absence.  

We believe that employers deserve to find the best benefits and insurance plans to meet their company's unique needs at a competitive price. By bringing together best-in-class data, thousands of broker customer reviews, and the industry's first brokerage rating–the M Score–our team delivers unparalleled transparency to employers and recognizes top brokers across the nation.

Our goal is for every employer to find the best insurance broker or consultant to match their unique needs–empowering employer choice through data-driven transparency and industry-leading tools is just the first step.

The Best Insurance Brokers in Tampa

BROKERAGE

AVERAGE RATING

DETAILS

LEARN MORE

BKS Partners - Tampa, FL

mSore Logo

Score

Proprietary rating

BKS Partners is an award-winning, entrepreneur-led insurance brokerage firm delivering expertly crafted commercial and private insurance and risk management; employee benefits and benefit administration; asset and income protection; and risk mitigation strategies to clients wherever their passions and businesses take them.

More info

Brown & Brown - Clearwater, FL

mSore Logo

Score

Proprietary rating

Brown & Brown Insurance provides risk management solutions to help protect what our customers value most. Our culture is built on integrity, innovation, superior capabilities, and discipline. We view insurance differently and use our experience, carrier relationships, and principled customer focus to deliver first-class service and solutions.

More info

Excalibur Financial Group

mSore Logo

Score

Proprietary rating

Through innovation, reliability, and integrity, Excalibur Financial Group delivers the best possible value for your dollar. They are committed to meeting your specific insurance needs, whether it be homeowners' or auto coverage, life, or disability income protection.

More info

Grooms Benefit Solutions

mSore Logo

Score

Proprietary rating

We have built Grooms Benefit Solutions to be far more than just your average benefits broker. We’re employee benefit architect–strategic experts, thoughtful advisors, and creative explorers committed to solving your complex benefit challenges with individualized solutions.

More info

Hartin Dynamics - Tampa, FL

mSore Logo

Score

Proprietary rating

Hartin Dynamics helps employers take care of their most important asset: their people. We help simplify the employee benefits selection process and help your employees understand what they have. We are expert advisors that work alongside your team to help drive cost-containment while ensuring your employee benefits plan remains competitive.

More info

HUB International - Tampa, FL

mSore Logo

Score

Proprietary rating

We advise businesses and individuals on how to reach their goals. When you partner with us, you’re at the center of a vast network of risk, insurance, employee benefits, retirement, and wealth management specialists that bring clarity to a changing world with tailored solutions and unrelenting advocacy.

More info

M.E. Wilson - Tampa, FL

mSore Logo

Score

Proprietary rating

We strive to be the best at what we do and stand out among our peers. We seek to balance the needs of our clients, employees, and carriers in the most professional way possible. Simply put, taking good care of all our business and personal relationships is the key to our success.

More info

Mercer - Tampa, FL

mSore Logo

Score

Proprietary rating

At Mercer, we believe in building brighter futures. Together, we are redefining the world of work, reshaping retirement and investment outcomes, and unlocking real health and well-being.

More info

OneDigital - Tampa, FL

mSore Logo

Score

Proprietary rating

OneDigital (formerly GCD Insurance Consultants) is an independent, owner-operated agency with over 50 years of experience across employee benefits, human resources, and payroll administration. We believe that every client's needs are unique, and we strive to offer customized solutions in the ever-changing and complex world of healthcare.

More info

USI Insurance Services - Tampa, FL

mSore Logo

Score

Proprietary rating

USI is one of the largest insurance brokerage and consulting firms in the world, delivering property and casualty; employee benefits; personal risk; and program and retirement solutions to large risk management clients, middle market companies, smaller firms, and individuals.

More info

Ready to change your broker? Go to the above pages to schedule a consultation, or click below for us to match you with one.

Connect Me With a Broker

Looking for more exclusive content? Check out the latest over on the Mployer Advisor blog, or read our post “Can I Change My Insurance Broker?” for more information.  


Want more insights on how your employee benefits compare to companies in your region, industry, and similar employer size?
Download Your Custom Benefits Report Now
See How Your Employee Benefits Compare

Next Up

The Market Employment Summary for November 2024
Each month, Mployer Advisor breaks down the Bureau of Labor Statistics’ most recent State Employment and Unemployment Summary to highlight some employment trends across various markets. This is an overview of November’s report. 
The Most Common Job Openings Of The Future
‍In this piece, we take a look at what kind of job openings are going to be most prevalent between now and 2033, as well as the education level needed to access those opportunities.
3 Questions That Will Determine How The 2024 Elections Impact Employer-Sponsored Healthcare
Now that the 2024 elections are mostly in the books, how will the shifting balance of power affect employer-sponsored healthcare?