Retirement Planning

8 Common Mistakes to Avoid when Hiring a 401(k) Custodian

UPDATED ON
August 9, 2023
Mployer Advisor
Mployer Advisor
— Written By
Print Friendly and PDF

There are many regulatory and other duties that a 401(k) custodian must perform for a retirement plan that they manage. These requirements make hiring the right custodian a crucial decision that can impact the success and effectiveness of your company's retirement plan. A custodian is responsible for holding and safeguarding the plan assets, ensuring compliance with regulations, and providing essential administrative services.

Each of these makes a 401(k) plan custodian an essential part of the team that works to ensure that your plan is set up to best suit the needs of participants. To help you choose the right one for your plan’s unique needs, this article will cover 8 common mistakes to avoid when hiring a 401(k) plan custodian.

Not Conducting Adequate Research  

One of the most significant mistakes made by employers is not conducting thorough research on potential 401(k) custodians. Many simply seek out well-known financial institutions without fully exploring the other options that may be available to them, without even knowing if they will be the best fit.

Take the time to research and compare multiple custodians, considering factors such as their reputation, experience, service offerings, fees, and client reviews. An informed decision can lead to a more suitable custodian for your plan, especially for a small business that may be low on the priority list for a large financial firm.  

Failing to Understand Service Offerings  

401(k) custodians may offer a range of service options, from basic recordkeeping to more comprehensive plan administration and investment management. It's essential to understand the scope of services provided by each custodian and assess whether they align with your company's needs. Choosing a custodian that offers tailored solutions can significantly benefit plan participants and streamline plan management.

Overlooking Fee Structures  

The fees charged by 401(k) custodians can vary significantly and have a direct impact on the plan's overall costs and participant outcomes. Some custodians may have hidden fees or complex fee structures that can be challenging to understand. Look for transparent and competitive fee arrangements, and ensure you have a clear understanding of all costs involved.  

If you later find that the custodian you chose has hidden fees that change your cost/benefit analysis, it may be worth your effort to find a new one.

Ignoring Compliance and Regulatory Requirements  

401(k) plans are subject to various legal and regulatory requirements, including those set forth by the Internal Revenue Service (IRS), the Department of Labor (DOL), and the Employee Retirement Income Security Act (ERISA). Choosing a custodian that is experienced in retirement plan administration and compliance is critical. Failure to comply with regulations can result in costly penalties and liabilities for your company, even if done at the hands of your custodian. This makes it imperative to do your due diligence and find one who is dependable and has a history of meeting their requirements.

Not Considering Technology and User Experience  

A user-friendly and technologically advanced platform can greatly enhance the participant experience and encourage engagement with the retirement plan. Look for a custodian that offers a modern, intuitive, and accessible online interface for both employers and employees. A seamless user experience can lead to increased participation and better plan outcomes.  

Failing to Review Custodian's Reputation and Track Record  

A custodian's reputation and track record are indicative of their performance and commitment to client satisfaction. Consider reviewing client testimonials, case studies, and independent ratings to gauge the custodian's reliability and level of service. A custodian with a positive reputation and proven results is more likely to be a trustworthy and valuable partner.  

You may want to ask potential custodians for the contact information of their current or former clients. If they balk at the suggestion, that may be seen as a red flag that prevents you from getting firsthand testimonials of their performance.

Overlooking Customer Support and Accessibility  

Efficient and responsive customer support is essential when managing a retirement plan. Consider how accessible the custodian's support team is and how they handle inquiries and issues. Timely and helpful customer support can resolve problems quickly and ensure a positive experience for both employers and participants.  

Disregarding Fiduciary Services

 

Some custodians offer fiduciary services, which means they assume some or all of the fiduciary responsibilities for the plan. Engaging a custodian that acts as a fiduciary can provide an additional layer of protection for plan sponsors, as the custodian will share the responsibility of acting in the best interests of plan participants.  

The Bottom Line  

A 401(k) custodian has a major role to play in the administration and regulatory compliance of your plan. Choosing the right one that is the best fit for your plan is an important step in the process of building a plan for your employees, and should not be taken lightly.

Avoiding the common mistakes outlined above when hiring a 401(k) custodian is essential to establishing a successful and well-managed retirement plan. Conduct thorough research, understand the custodian's services and fee structures, ensure compliance with regulations, and prioritize customer support and user experience. A well-chosen 401(k) custodian can play a vital role in enhancing the retirement readiness of your employees and providing peace of mind for plan sponsors.

Want more insights on how your employee benefits compare to companies in your region, industry, and similar employer size?
Download Your Custom Benefits Report Now
See How Your Employee Benefits Compare

Next Up

The Market Employment Summary for December 2024
Each month, Mployer Advisor breaks down the Bureau of Labor Statistics’ most recent State Employment and Unemployment Summary to highlight some employment trends across various markets. This is an overview of December’s report.
The Employment Situation for December 2024
The latest economic release from the Bureau of Labor Statistics reports that the U.S. job market rebounded after a sluggish month in October to add 227 thousand new jobs last month as the unemployment rate ticked up slightly to 4.2%.
Introducing Insights+ The Next Evolution In Employee Benefits Evaluation & Value-Capture Tools
‍We are excited to announce the launch of Insights+, a service that enables employers to see exactly how their benefits measure up against the competition.