Open-Panel vs. Closed-Panel System

In the insurance industry, an open-panel system refers to a health insurance plan that allows policyholders to receive medical services from any healthcare provider or facility that accepts the insurance plan. In contrast, a closed-panel system limits the network of healthcare providers and facilities that policyholders can receive medical services from.

An example of an open-panel system is a Preferred Provider Organization (PPO) plan. Under a PPO plan, policyholders have the flexibility to choose any healthcare provider or facility they wish, although they may receive financial incentives to use providers that are part of the PPO network. PPO plans typically have higher premiums than closed-panel plans, but they also offer greater flexibility and choice.

On the other hand, a Health Maintenance Organization (HMO) plan is an example of a closed-panel system. Under an HMO plan, policyholders are typically required to choose a primary care physician (PCP) who coordinates all their medical care. Policyholders are generally required to receive all medical services from providers within the HMO network, and typically need a referral from their PCP to see a specialist. HMO plans generally have lower premiums than PPO plans, but they also offer less flexibility and choice.

Here are some key features of open-panel vs. closed-panel systems:

Open-Panel System:

  • Policyholders can choose any healthcare provider or facility that accepts the insurance plan
  • Typically, no referral is needed to see a specialist
  • Policyholders may receive financial incentives to use providers that are part of the insurance plan's network
  • Higher premiums than closed-panel plans, but offer greater flexibility and choice

Closed-Panel System:

  • Policyholders are typically required to choose a primary care physician (PCP) who coordinates all their medical care
  • Policyholders must receive all medical services from providers within the insurance plan's network, unless in case of emergencies
  • Referral from PCP is often needed to see a specialist
  • Lower premiums than open-panel plans, but offer less flexibility and choice.

Next Up

A Texas court ruled that American Airlines breached its ERISA duty of loyalty by failing to properly oversee BlackRock’s ESG-driven investment decisions. The decision could put millions of employers at legal risk if upheld. Are ESG investments in retirement plans now a liability?
The latest economic release from the Bureau of Labor Statistics reports that the U.S. job market added just under 150 thousand jobs last month while unemployment ticked down one-tenth of a point to 4% to close out the last such economic report with data collected under the Biden administration.
Centers of Excellence (COEs) may have peaked. While mid-sized employers increased adoption, the largest companies are scaling back. Is this a temporary dip or a shift in employer healthcare strategy?