McCarran-Ferguson Act (1945)

The McCarran-Ferguson Act is a federal law passed by Congress in 1945 that gives states the power to regulate the insurance industry within their borders. It also exempts insurance companies from some federal antitrust laws, allowing them to share information and collaborate on setting rates and other industry practices. Some key features of the McCarran-Ferguson Act include:

  • State regulation: The law recognizes the authority of individual states to regulate the insurance industry within their borders. This means that insurance companies must comply with state laws regarding licensing, rates, and other practices.

  • Limited federal oversight: The law limits the ability of the federal government to regulate the insurance industry, leaving most regulatory authority to the states.

  • Antitrust exemption: The law exempts insurance companies from some federal antitrust laws, allowing them to share information and collaborate on setting rates and other industry practices.

The impact of the McCarran-Ferguson Act on employee benefits is primarily related to the regulation of insurance policies offered by employers. Because the law gives states the primary authority to regulate insurance, employers offering insurance benefits to their employees must comply with state insurance laws. This can include requirements for coverage, rate setting, and other practices that may vary from state to state. The law also allows insurance companies to collaborate on setting rates, which can impact the cost of insurance benefits offered to employees.

Next Up

This month, Catalyst makes prospecting and outreach easier with AI-powered email creation, more powerful search filters, improved industry and Workers' Comp data, broader access to Mployer data through AI assistants, and improvements to Advanced Analytics.
According to Mployer Insights’ 2026 analysis of 76,000+ employer benefit plans, basic group life insurance achieves near-universal participation with an 83% employer offer rate and a 97% employee enrollment rate, driven by the fact that 96% of basic plans are noncontributory (100% employer-paid). While 47% of employers structure life insurance as a variable multiple of earnings—with 1x salary serving as the dominant national standard (62% of multiple-based plans)—flat-dollar benefit options vary widely from $8,500 (10th percentile) to $48,793 (90th percentile). Additionally, 92% of employers offer employee-paid voluntary life insurance to allow workers to bridge the gap toward the recommended 10–12x salary coverage target.
According to Mployer Insights’ 2026 analysis of 76,000+ employer benefit plans, disability insurance remains a major market differentiator, with only 41% of U.S. employers offering short-term disability (STD) and 38% offering long-term disability (LTD). While 60% salary replacement serves as the national standard across both benefit types, standard plan designs disproportionately expose higher earners due to median benefit caps of $1,602/week for STD and $8,273/month for LTD. Furthermore, alignment between STD benefit durations (median 26 weeks) and LTD elimination periods (68% at 90 days) remains a critical area for plan structure optimization.